1. Home
  2. Nation
  3. Modi govt fights pressure to lock down India as coronavirus deaths rise

Modi govt fights pressure to lock down India as coronavirus deaths rise

By Saima Siddiqui 
Updated Date
Modi govt fights pressure to lock down India as coronavirus deaths rise

New Delhi: Just two weeks ago, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had asked all the states to only consider lockdown “as the last option,” but now everyone from his political allies to top business leaders and US President Joe Biden’s chief medical adviser see lockdown as the only way to control the worsening virus outbreak in India.

Also Read :- Kerala extends lockdown till May 23; 4 districts to be put under 'triple lockdown'

The debate has been complicated by Modi’s move last year to impose a nationwide lockdown without warning, spurring a humanitarian crisis as migrant workers fled on foot to rural areas. However, Modi seems to avoid that criticism again, particularly after BJP failed to win West Bengal assembly polls when votes were counted Sunday, even states run by his party are ignoring his advice.

“One of the problems is this false narrative that it’s either a full lockdown, which equates to economic disaster, or no lockdown, which is a public health disaster,” said Catherine Blish, an infectious disease specialist and global health expert at Stanford Medicine in California. “What’s happening now is a health and an economic disaster. If you have huge swaths of your population getting sick, that’s not good for your population or your economy.”

In the past week, television channels and social media have been flooded with grim scenes of overcrowded crematoriums and desperate pleas for oxygen from hospitals. On Tuesday, the country reported more than 357,000 new infections to cross 20 million cases, as well as 3,449 deaths.

The Indian currency has also turned into Asia’s worst-performing currency this quarter from being the best in the previous quarter as foreigners pulled about $1.8 billion from the nation’s stocks and bonds. Additionally, the benchmark S&P BSE Sensex Index declined about 1.5% as investors turned cautious amid the deadly outbreak.

Also Read :- Goa's hospital oxygen crisis claims 13 more lives; 75 Covid-19 patients die in 4 days

Also Read :- As "Black Fungus" cases rise,Health Minister Dr Vardhan on symptoms, Do's And Don'ts

India’s richest banker Uday Kotak, who heads the Confederation of Indian Industry, urged the government to deploy the military to help care for patients and to take the “strongest national steps including curtailing economic activity to reduce suffering.” “We must heed expert advice on this subject — from India and abroad,” he said.

Also Read :- Ex-AAP MLA Jarnail Singh passes away, Kejriwal condoles his demise

This represents a shift from India’s top business leaders as in April, a survey of the confederation’s members showed that they were against lockdowns and wanted swift vaccination. But in the past month, however, the collapsing health infrastructure and mounting death toll has revealed the extent the crisis. A lack of adequate vaccine doses has only added to the chaos.

Although policy makers have signaled they are ready to take steps to support growth, economists say a failure to flatten the virus curve could exert pressure on monetary and fiscal policies at a time when most of the conventional space available has already been used.

Right now the most immediately effective way to break the chain of transmission seems to keep people far enough apart that the virus can’t jump from one to another. Some experts, including Anthony S Fauci, the top US infectious disease doctor, say a temporary shut down is important to break the chain.

However, others say complete national lockdown isn’t possible and would be disastrous for the poor, who have already suffered the most during the outbreak. The central government has left it open for states to decide on local lockdowns, and places like the national capital Delhi and the financial hub Mumbai have imposed restrictions, though they are less strict than last year.

Meanwhile, talking about the people who live hand-to-mouth must go out every day to find something to eat or earn a day’s wages, Kim Mulholland, an Australian pediatrician and leader of the infection and immunity group at the Murdoch Children’s Research Institute in Melbourne, expressed his worries over lockdown’s impact on people’s lives .

When India hospitals are already struggling for oxygen and bodies are piling up at crematoriums, a blanket lockdown may only add to the misery. Also a second complete lockdown may once again prompt a rush of workers from cities to their home towns and villages, helping the virus spread to the hinterlands.

Instead of a strict shutdown, experts said, local governments could restrict activities where it is difficult to maintain social distancing.

Also Read :- In pandemic milestone,US ends masks, social distancing for those fully vaccinated

“I would absolutely curtail indoor retail, restaurants, shops, as much as possible anything that has people getting together indoors,” said Ashish Jha, the dean of Brown University School of Public Health. “I would absolutely ban any large congregations outside, though it’s hard in places in India where things can get pretty crowded naturally.”

Further reading:
For the latest news and reviews, follow us on Facebook and Twitter ...
X